The NLRB’s Atlanta Opera Ruling: Shifting Standards for Independent Contractors and Impact on Businesses

On August 12, 2021, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) issued a significant ruling in the Atlanta Opera case, overturning its previous standard for classifying workers as “independent contractors” or “employees” under the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). The decision has significant implications for businesses and workers across the United States, particularly those that rely on independent contractors as part of their business model.

The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) is a federal law that guarantees workers the right to unionize, engage in collective bargaining, and take other collective actions to improve their working conditions and benefits. The law applies to most private-sector employers and their employees.

The Atlanta Opera case involved a group of makeup artists, wig artists, and hairstylists who worked at the Atlanta Opera. The NLRB Board majority determined that these workers were not independent contractors but instead were “employees” under the NLRA.

For decades, the NLRB has used a multifactor common-law test to determine whether a worker is an “independent contractor” exempt from the NLRA’s protections or an “employee” entitled to those protections. The test considers factors such as the worker’s level of control over their work, the degree of skill required to perform the work, and the extent to which the worker is economically dependent on the employer.

Employer’s right to exercise control over worker

When applying these factors, the Board and courts have traditionally focused on an employer’s right to exercise control over the worker. Specifically, they have looked at which “controls” companies can use without transforming a contractor into an employee.

Facts of FedEx I

In 2014, the NLRB applied this test in the case of FedEx Home Delivery, in which it found that a group of drivers working as contractors were actually “employees” under the NLRA. The board concluded that FedEx exercised significant control over the drivers, including setting their work schedules, providing them with training and equipment, and requiring them to follow specific policies and procedures.

Overruling of SuperShuttle and reinstatement of FedEx II standard in Atlanta Opera

In 2019, the Board established a new standard in the case of SuperShuttle DFW, Inc., which emphasized the importance of “entrepreneurial opportunity” when determining whether a worker is an independent contractor. The Board held that the existence of such an opportunity is “an important animating principle by which to evaluate” the common-law factors.

At the Atlanta Opera, the board majority overruled SuperShuttle and reinstated its previous standard from FedEx II. This standard places greater emphasis on an employer’s right to control the worker rather than the worker’s opportunity for entrepreneurial activity.

In dissent from the Atlanta Opera majority decision, member Kaplan argued that the majority’s decision conflicted with D.C. Circuit precedent and that the Board could have found that the hair stylists, makeup artists, and wig artists were “employees” under the NLRA without overruling SuperShuttle.

Implications for businesses and workers

The NLRB’s decision in Atlanta Opera could have far-reaching implications for businesses that rely on independent contractors as part of their business model. Companies that view their workers as being outside the scope of the NLRA could become vulnerable to union organizing and unfair labor practice charges.

Furthermore, the decision may result in increased unionization efforts and demands for collective bargaining by workers who are now categorized as “employees” under the NLRA. Businesses may also face legal challenges from workers seeking back pay, benefits, and other compensation that they would have been entitled to as “employees” under the law.

The NLRB’s ruling in Atlanta Opera creates a new level of complexity for businesses that regularly use independent contractors as part of their business model. Companies must now carefully evaluate their relationships with contractors to determine whether they are correctly classified under the NLRA and other labor laws. Failure to do so can result in legal and financial consequences that can have a significant impact on a business’s bottom line and reputation.

Explore more

Revolutionizing SaaS with Customer Experience Automation

Imagine a SaaS company struggling to keep up with a flood of customer inquiries, losing valuable clients due to delayed responses, and grappling with the challenge of personalizing interactions at scale. This scenario is all too common in today’s fast-paced digital landscape, where customer expectations for speed and tailored service are higher than ever, pushing businesses to adopt innovative solutions.

Trend Analysis: AI Personalization in Healthcare

Imagine a world where every patient interaction feels as though the healthcare system knows them personally—down to their favorite sports team or specific health needs—transforming a routine call into a moment of genuine connection that resonates deeply. This is no longer a distant dream but a reality shaped by artificial intelligence (AI) personalization in healthcare. As patient expectations soar for

Trend Analysis: Digital Banking Global Expansion

Imagine a world where accessing financial services is as simple as a tap on a smartphone, regardless of where someone lives or their economic background—digital banking is making this vision a reality at an unprecedented pace, disrupting traditional financial systems by prioritizing accessibility, efficiency, and innovation. This transformative force is reshaping how millions manage their money. In today’s tech-driven landscape,

Trend Analysis: AI-Driven Data Intelligence Solutions

In an era where data floods every corner of business operations, the ability to transform raw, chaotic information into actionable intelligence stands as a defining competitive edge for enterprises across industries. Artificial Intelligence (AI) has emerged as a revolutionary force, not merely processing data but redefining how businesses strategize, innovate, and respond to market shifts in real time. This analysis

What’s New and Timeless in B2B Marketing Strategies?

Imagine a world where every business decision hinges on a single click, yet the underlying reasons for that click have remained unchanged for decades, reflecting the enduring nature of human behavior in commerce. In B2B marketing, the landscape appears to evolve at breakneck speed with digital tools and data-driven tactics, but are these shifts as revolutionary as they seem? This