Texas Court Rules in Favor of HCDE in Assistant Principal’s Contract Non-Renewal Case

In a recent case, the Texas Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the Harris County Department of Education (HCDE) in a dispute over the non-renewal of an assistant principal’s contract. The court found that HCDE provided legitimate reasons, including an alleged privacy violation, insubordination, and failure to follow official directives, for its decision. This article provides a detailed overview of the case, from the background and disciplinary actions to the discrimination charges and retaliation allegations.

Background

The controversy began when HCDE opted not to renew the contract of an assistant principal. The move was based on several reasons, including an alleged privacy violation, insubordination, and failure to comply with official directives. These factors gave rise to concerns about the assistant principal’s conduct and performance within the educational institution.

HCDE’s Disciplinary Actions

Following the incident, HCDE denied the assistant principal’s requested benefits and assault leave. Upon investigation, it was determined that the principal was the instigator of the altercation, leading to disciplinary action against him by HCDE.

Discrimination Charge and Retaliation Allegations

In June 2017, the assistant principal filed a discrimination charge with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). He alleged that HCDE had retaliated against him for opposing age and disability discrimination faced by another employee by denying him benefits. Retaliation claims were brought forward, adding complexity to the case.

Racial Discrimination Allegation

The assistant principal also claimed racial discrimination, stating that the school principal allowed the investigating officer to develop a biased view that he was the provocateur in the altercation. This alleged biased perspective suggested that racial discrimination may have influenced the investigation and subsequent disciplinary actions.

Lawsuit and Violation Claims

Frustrated with the events, the assistant principal filed a lawsuit against HCDE in October 2017. The lawsuit alleged various violations, including violations of applicable codes and the Texas Whistleblower Act, which protects employees from retaliation for reporting illegal activities.

Discrimination Charge with TWC

In addition to the EEOC discrimination charge, the assistant principal filed a discrimination charge with the Texas Workforce Commission (TWC) in July 2018. The TWC charge claimed discrimination on the grounds of race, color, and disability, along with allegations of retaliation for various actions taken by the assistant principal.

In May 2018, HCDE’s board of trustees informed the assistant principal of their recommendation not to renew his contract based on his failure to follow supervisors’ directives. This recommendation formed the basis for the non-renewal decision.

Second Discrimination Charge

In response to further developments, the assistant principal filed a second discrimination charge with the TWC, highlighting additional claims of discrimination and retaliation for various actions he had taken.

After a careful review of the case, the Texas Court of Appeals ruled in favor of HCDE, affirming the legitimacy of their decision not to renew the assistant principal’s contract. The court found that HCDE had provided valid reasons for their actions, including the alleged privacy violation, insubordination, and failure to follow official directives. The court’s decision upholds HCDE’s assertion that the assistant principal’s termination was based on legitimate grounds.

Despite the assistant principal’s allegations of discrimination and retaliation, the court’s ruling serves as confirmation of HCDE’s procedures and actions in this particular case. Moving forward, this decision provides important legal clarity and reaffirms the importance of adhering to established policies and protocols within educational institutions.

Explore more

Mastering Digital Marketing for NGOs in 2025: A Guide

In a world where over 5 billion people are online daily, NGOs face an unprecedented opportunity to amplify their missions through digital channels, yet the challenge of cutting through the noise has never been greater. Imagine an organization like Dianova International, working across 17 countries on critical issues like health, education, and gender equality, struggling to reach the right audience

How Can Leaders Prepare for the Cognitive Revolution?

Embracing the Intelligence Age: Why Leaders Must Act Now Imagine a world where machines not only perform tasks but also think, learn, and adapt alongside human workers, transforming every industry from manufacturing to healthcare in ways we are only beginning to comprehend. This is not a distant dream but the reality of the cognitive industrial revolution, often referred to as

Why Do Leaders Lack Empathy During Layoffs? New Survey Shows

Introduction In the current business landscape, layoffs have become a stark reality, cutting across industries from technology to retail, with countless employees facing the uncertainty of job loss. A staggering 53% of workers globally express fear of being laid off within the next year, reflecting a pervasive anxiety that shapes workplace dynamics and underscores a critical challenge for leaders. How

Employee Engagement Crisis: How to Restore Workplace Happiness

We’re thrilled to sit down with Ling-Yi Tsai, a renowned HRTech expert with decades of experience helping organizations navigate change through innovative technology. With a deep focus on HR analytics and the seamless integration of tech in recruitment, onboarding, and talent management, Ling-Yi offers invaluable insights into the pressing challenges of employee engagement and workplace well-being. In this conversation, we

How Is AI Transforming Digital Marketing Strategies?

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is rapidly becoming a cornerstone of digital marketing, fundamentally altering how brands connect with audiences in an increasingly crowded online space. As businesses grapple with the challenge of capturing consumer attention amidst endless streams of content, AI offers a lifeline by providing tools that personalize experiences, streamline operations, and deliver data-driven insights. This technological shift is not