California Court Rules that Injured Intern is an Employee Entitled to Workers’ Compensation Benefits

In July 2015, a young woman was on her way to a training class for her internship when she was injured in a motor vehicle accident. The question of whether she was an employee or not came into dispute. Recently, the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board of California found that the woman, who was seeking workers’ compensation benefits for her injuries, was an employee at the time of the accident. This ruling has major implications for businesses that offer internships, as they may have thought they were not responsible for providing workers’ compensation coverage to interns.

Background of the case

The contract offered the woman an internship position as a business analyst in the defendant’s training program. She started attending the training classes at the defendant’s office in Fremont, California.

The Motor Vehicle Accident and Injury

In July 2015, while the woman was being driven by her friend to a training class, they were involved in a motor vehicle accident. As a result, the woman sustained injuries.

Debate Over Applicant’s Employment Status

The defendant argued that the woman was not an employee and therefore not entitled to workers’ compensation benefits because she was an intern. They claimed that the internship was strictly a training program and did not involve an employer-employee relationship.

Business Analyst Agreement Duties and Responsibilities

The business analyst agreement required the woman to perform duties and responsibilities that went beyond simple training or education. The defendant argued that these duties were part of the training program and did not make her an employee.

Application of Borello v. Department of Industrial Relations Ruling

The panel that reviewed the case cited the ruling in Borello v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989), which outlines the criteria for determining whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor. Under this ruling, an employer must establish that the worker is free from the control and direction of the employer and that the worker is engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business.

Evidence supporting applicant’s status as an employee

The panel held that the evidence favored the woman’s status as an employee, not as an independent contractor. The evidence showed that the defendant retained all the necessary control over its training program and over the woman’s activities as an intern. This included controlling the work schedule, the content of the training program, and supervising the woman’s work.

Secondary Borello Factors Favoring Employee Status

In addition to the primary factors, the panel ruled that the secondary Borello factors also supported the woman’s employee status. These factors included whether the employer or the worker supplied the tools and equipment for the work, the length of time for which the services were to be rendered, and the method of payment.

Defendant’s Assumption of Transportation Risks

The panel additionally found that the defendant clearly assumed the risks relating to transportation. The defendant required interns to attend training classes at their office, and the woman had no control over how she was transported to the training. Therefore, in assuming the transportation risk, the defendant was essentially treating the woman as an employee.

This case demonstrates that businesses can’t use the label of “intern” to avoid providing workers’ compensation benefits. The criteria for determining employee status are based on the extent of control and direction an employer exercises over the worker. In this case, the evidence suggests that the defendant had enough control over the intern’s training program and work to establish an employment relationship. Consequently, the court classified the intern as an employee, which entitled her to workers’ compensation benefits for the injuries she sustained. This ruling should serve as a reminder to companies offering internships that they must comply with all relevant labor laws and provide their interns with appropriate compensation and benefits.

Explore more

How Does Databricks’ Data Science Agent Boost Analytics?

In an era where data drives decision-making across industries, the sheer volume and complexity of information can overwhelm even the most skilled data practitioners, making efficiency a constant challenge. Databricks, a prominent player in the data analytics and AI space, has unveiled a transformative tool designed to address this issue head-on. Known as the Data Science Agent, this feature enhances

What Are the Best Books for Data Science Beginners in 2025?

I’m thrilled to sit down with Dominic Jainy, an IT professional whose deep expertise in artificial intelligence, machine learning, and blockchain has made him a go-to voice in the tech world. With a passion for exploring how these cutting-edge fields transform industries, Dominic also has a keen interest in guiding aspiring data scientists. Today, we’re diving into the best resources

How Is ESG Reshaping European Employment and Labor Laws?

Imagine a corporate landscape where sustainability isn’t just a buzzword but a legal mandate, where social equity dictates hiring practices, and governance defines accountability at every level. Across Europe, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles are no longer optional for businesses; they are becoming entrenched in employment and labor laws, reshaping how companies operate. This roundup dives into diverse perspectives

How Does Integrity Jobs Redefine Staffing with a Human Touch?

Introduction to Integrity Jobs and Staffing Challenges In today’s fast-paced job market, finding the right career fit or the perfect candidate often feels like an uphill battle, with countless resumes lost in digital black holes and employers struggling to identify talent that truly aligns with their needs. This challenge underscores a critical need for a staffing approach that prioritizes genuine

Data Centers Tackle 2025 Environmental Compliance Challenges

In 2025, the data center industry stands at a critical juncture, grappling with an unprecedented surge in energy demands while facing intense pressure to meet stringent environmental standards. Imagine a world where the digital backbone supporting everything from cloud computing to artificial intelligence consumes more power than entire cities, yet must shrink its carbon footprint to near zero. This paradox