AI vs Human Endeavors in Phishing: An Examination of the IBM X-Force Research on Cybersecurity Threats

Phishing, a technique employed by threat actors to deceive individuals into divulging sensitive information, remains the primary infection vector for cybersecurity incidents. IBM X-Force undertook a groundbreaking research project led by Chief People Hacker Stephanie “Snow” Carruthers, exploring the efficiency of human-written phishing emails compared to those generated by AI language models. Their findings shed light on the factors contributing to the success of human-written emails, the looming threat of AI tools, and offer recommendations to counter the growing influence of generative AI in cybercrime.

The research project by IBM X-Force, under the guidance of Stephanie Carruthers, aimed to examine the effectiveness of human-written and AI-generated phishing emails. Carruthers sought to ascertain whether AI-based approaches could outperform the human touch in deceiving recipients.

Click Rates of Human-Written vs. AI-Generated Phishing Emails

Analyzing the data, Carruthers discovered that human-written phishing emails exhibited a 3% higher click rate compared to their AI-generated counterparts. Delving deeper, it was revealed that the AI-generated emails garnered an 11% click rate, while human-written emails proved slightly more successful at 14%.

Factors Contributing to the Success of Human-Written Emails

The researchers attribute the success of human-written emails to their ability to appeal to human emotional intelligence. These emails were crafted carefully, exploiting psychological triggers and persuading recipients to take action. Furthermore, the selection of a specific program within the organization, instead of employing vague or generic topics, allowed the human-written emails to appear more authentic and relevant.

Threat of AI Tools for Phishing

The emergence of tools such as WormGPT, an industrial variant of ChatGPT, raises concerns over the potential for AI models to bypass ethical guardrails and facilitate sophisticated phishing attacks. These unrestrained AI versions offer a streamlined approach for attackers to scale their operations, intensifying the threat faced by organizations and individuals.

Phishing as the Common Infection Vector

IBM’s 2023 Threat Intelligence Index substantiates that phishing remains the most prevalent infection vector for cybersecurity incidents. With the continued evolution of AI and its integration in cybercrime, the significance of tackling phishing attacks becomes increasingly crucial.

Potential Use of Generative AI for Attackers

Carruthers highlights the possibility of generative AI augmenting open-source intelligence analysis for attackers. Though not explored in the research project, the growing sophistication of generative AI models may provide cybercriminals with advanced tools to orchestrate more efficient and targeted phishing campaigns.

As the research conducted by IBM X-Force reveals, human-written phishing emails still exhibit a superior success rate compared to their AI-generated counterparts. The ability to target emotional intelligence and adopt a personalized approach remains a fundamental advantage. However, as generative AI continues to advance, the threat landscape evolves, necessitating a holistic and collaborative approach to cybersecurity. Adapting preventive measures, enhancing employee training, and remaining vigilant against the capabilities of generative AI are crucial for organizations to protect themselves from the ever-growing peril of phishing attacks.

Explore more

Why Should Leaders Invest in Employee Career Growth?

In today’s fast-paced business landscape, a staggering statistic reveals the stakes of neglecting employee development: turnover costs the median S&P 500 company $480 million annually due to talent loss, underscoring a critical challenge for leaders. This immense financial burden highlights the urgent need to retain skilled individuals and maintain a competitive edge through strategic initiatives. Employee career growth, often overlooked

Making Time for Questions to Boost Workplace Curiosity

Introduction to Fostering Inquiry at Work Imagine a bustling office where deadlines loom large, meetings are packed with agendas, and every minute counts—yet no one dares to ask a clarifying question for fear of derailing the schedule. This scenario is all too common in modern workplaces, where the pressure to perform often overshadows the need for curiosity. Fostering an environment

Embedded Finance: From SaaS Promise to SME Practice

Imagine a small business owner managing daily operations through a single software platform, seamlessly handling not just inventory or customer relations but also payments, loans, and business accounts without ever stepping into a bank. This is the transformative vision of embedded finance, a trend that integrates financial services directly into vertical Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) platforms, turning them into indispensable tools for

DevOps Tools: Gateways to Major Cyberattacks Exposed

In the rapidly evolving digital ecosystem, DevOps tools have emerged as indispensable assets for organizations aiming to streamline software development and IT operations with unmatched efficiency, making them critical to modern business success. Platforms like GitHub, Jira, and Confluence enable seamless collaboration, allowing teams to manage code, track projects, and document workflows at an accelerated pace. However, this very integration

Trend Analysis: Agentic DevOps in Digital Transformation

In an era where digital transformation remains a critical yet elusive goal for countless enterprises, the frustration of stalled progress is palpable— over 70% of initiatives fail to meet expectations, costing billions annually in wasted resources and missed opportunities. This staggering reality underscores a persistent struggle to modernize IT infrastructure amid soaring costs and sluggish timelines. As companies grapple with