Navigating the Aftermath of McLaren Macomb: The Importance of NLRA-Compliant Severance Agreements for US Employers

The National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) recently made a significant decision in the case of McLaren Macomb, which has implications for both union and non-union employers in the United States. According to this decision, merely offering a severance agreement to employees can be a violation of the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) if the agreement’s terms interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees’ NLRA rights. This ruling is a wake-up call for employers to review their severance agreements and ensure that they comply with the NLRA.

Assessing the Legality of Severance Agreements Under the NLRA

The McLane Macomb decision has significant implications for employers in terms of how they draft and enforce their severance agreements. The NLRB assesses the legality of severance agreements under the NLRA by examining whether their terms interfere with employees’ NLRA rights. This can include provisions that restrict employees from forming a union or engaging in collective bargaining. If a provision in a severance agreement affects employees’ NLRA rights, it can be deemed unlawful.

The NLRB’s ruling on Confidentiality and Non-Disparagement Provisions

The NLRB has found that both the confidentiality and non-disparagement provisions of the McLaren Macomb severance agreement were unlawful. The confidentiality provision broadly prohibited an employee from disclosing the agreement to any third-party, including the Board and other employees. The non-disparagement provision prohibited an employee from making statements that disparage or harm the employer, its entities, or its representatives without any temporal limitation.

Why the Confidentiality Provision was Unlawful

The NLRB found that the confidentiality provision was unlawful because it interfered with employees’ NLRA rights. Employees may need to discuss the terms of a severance agreement with their colleagues or with the Board to effectively exercise their NLRA rights. By preventing employees from discussing the agreement with a third party, the confidentiality provision restricted employees’ ability to exercise their rights.

Why the Non-Disparagement Provision was Unlawful

Similarly, the NLRB found the non-disparagement provision unlawful because it prevented employees from making statements that could potentially harm the employer’s image. This prohibition can interfere with employees’ right to engage in concerted activity under the NLRA.

Applying the Decision to Unionized and Non-Unionized Employers

The decision in McLaren Macomb has broad implications, regardless of whether an employer is unionized or non-unionized. Most private sector employers in the United States are covered by the NLRA, which means that most severance agreements would also be subject to the NLRB’s scrutiny. This ruling sends a clear message to employers that they must carefully draft their severance agreements if they want to avoid violating the NLRA and exposing themselves to legal risk.

The Likelihood of NLRA Violations in Severance Agreements

Given the broad scope of the NLRA and the specificity of its provisions, it is likely that many employers unknowingly include language that violates the NLRA in their severance agreements. In light of the McLaren Macomb decision, employers should carefully review their severance agreements with the help of experienced labor counsel to ensure compliance with the NLRA.

Recommendations for Employers

Employers should be proactive in preventing NLRA violations in their severance agreements by carefully reviewing the provisions of each agreement. Employers should also consider providing training to HR personnel and others who are responsible for drafting and administering severance agreements to ensure they are compliant with the NLRA.

The NLRB’s ruling in McLaren Macomb has brought increased attention to employers’ severance agreements and their compliance with the NLRA. Employers must take this ruling seriously and ensure that their severance agreements do not restrict employees’ NLRA rights. By doing so, employers can limit their legal risk and create a more positive relationship with their employees. Careful review and compliance with the NLRA should be the top priority for any employer drafting or administering a severance agreement.

Explore more

Is Skills Velocity Key to Future Business Success?

In today’s rapidly evolving business landscape, the concept of skills velocity is emerging as a crucial determinant of organizational success. This concept emphasizes agility in acquiring new skills over the traditional focus on deep, static expertise. As industries face unprecedented disruptions, this paradigm shift is becoming especially relevant. Businesses need to remain competitive in a dynamic market, which requires a

Trend Analysis: Mental Health in Workplaces

Imagine a workplace where employees can openly discuss mental health challenges without fear of stigma or discrimination. The significance of mental health in employment has grown exponentially, with increasing awareness and initiatives that support individuals struggling with mental health disorders. In recent years, there has been a noticeable shift in how businesses prioritize mental well-being. This article explores the current

Can AI Legally Handle Hiring and Firing Decisions?

As artificial intelligence technology permeates the realm of human resources, the conversation about its role in hiring and firing decisions intensifies. In the current business landscape, AI has become a prominent tool that aids HR departments in streamlining recruitment processes. From screening resumes to scheduling interviews, AI simplifies tasks that traditionally consumed significant time and effort. However, the efficiency brought

People Analytics Market Slows, Emphasizes AI and Partnerships

As organizations become increasingly reliant on data-driven decisions to shape their operations, the people analytics market, once on an upward trajectory, is encountering waves of change. This sector, which is expected to reach a staggering $10.4 billion in 2025, is experiencing a noticeable slowdown in growth. From a dynamic 41% growth rate in the previous year, it is now projected

Office Design Strategies to Combat Employee Burnout

The modern workplace faces an increasing challenge that leaders cannot afford to ignore: employee burnout. This pervasive issue manifests in various ways, from diminished focus and emotional exhaustion to a pervasive sense of disengagement. Recent studies highlight its alarming impact on productivity, with Gallup’s State of the Global Workplace report revealing a significant decline in employee engagement. The report noted