Is Dismissal Justified When Safety Rules Are Breached?

Safety in the workplace is paramount. When an employee breaches a vital safety rule, it not only puts their own life at risk but also endangers their colleagues and the integrity of the company. A last-chance agreement is often a final warning, with dismissal as the consequence of any subsequent transgressions.

Case Study: Upholding Termination for Safety Breach

A recent case saw an arbitrator uphold an employee’s termination for breaking a critical safety protocol and lying about it. Despite the employer’s shortcomings in fulfilling the agreement’s terms, the arbitrator underscored the non-negotiable nature of safety and honesty.

Employer’s Right to Terminate

This ruling affirms that even if employers fail to meet certain aspects of a last-chance agreement, they still retain the right to terminate employment when key rules are violated. The crux is clear: safety and honesty are not just policies; they are foundational to the trust necessary in any employment relationship. Consequently, courts and arbitral bodies are signaling a firm stance on the enforcement of these principles, regardless of the surrounding circumstances.

The Bottom Line

The message is unequivocal: breach of safety rules, compounded by dishonesty, can indeed justify dismissal. The case serves as a stern reminder to employees about the severe implications of disregarding safety measures and the critical importance of maintaining integrity at all times.

Explore more