Why Is SEO Failing and How Should Marketers Refocus?

Introduction

Welcome to an insightful conversation with Aisha Amaira, a renowned MarTech expert whose passion for blending technology with marketing has transformed how businesses harness customer insights. With a deep background in CRM marketing technology and customer data platforms, Aisha has dedicated her career to helping companies navigate the ever-evolving digital landscape. In this interview, we dive into the current challenges in SEO, the impact of AI on search strategies, and the fundamental shifts businesses must embrace to stay relevant. From understanding user intent to ensuring discoverability, Aisha shares actionable insights on refocusing marketing efforts for meaningful results in today’s tech-driven world.

How do you see the current state of SEO, and what are the biggest hurdles preventing it from delivering results?

Right now, SEO isn’t functioning as effectively as it could for many businesses, not because it’s inherently broken, but due to a combination of inaction and misplaced focus. A major hurdle is what I call paralysis—many companies are hesitant to invest in organic search because they’re unsure of the direction to take amid constant changes. Another issue is the overwhelming hype around AI, which distracts teams from core strategies as they chase the latest trends or buzzwords. Lastly, there’s a troubling neglect of the basics, like ensuring sites are crawlable and content is relevant. These fundamentals are often overlooked in the rush to adopt new tools, and that’s where businesses are losing ground.

Can you elaborate on how this paralysis in organic search manifests for businesses, and what it costs them?

Paralysis shows up as a kind of decision fatigue. Businesses, especially those reliant on organic traffic, often freeze when faced with uncertainty about algorithm updates or emerging technologies. They delay content updates, hesitate on site improvements, or avoid investing in search altogether. This inaction costs them visibility and relevance—while they’re stuck, competitors who adapt are capturing their audience. For information-based businesses, this is particularly damaging as AI-driven answers now bypass their sites entirely, cutting into traffic they once relied on.

How is the buzz around AI diverting attention from effective search strategies?

The AI hype is a double-edged sword. It’s exciting because it offers new ways to understand and predict user behavior, but it’s also a massive distraction. Companies get caught up in experimenting with every new AI acronym or tool—whether it’s large language models or answer engines—without a clear plan. This scattershot approach pulls resources away from building a cohesive search strategy. Instead of refining content to match user intent, they’re chasing shiny objects, which often leads to wasted time and budget with little measurable impact on rankings or engagement.

What core SEO fundamentals are being neglected, and why do they remain critical even with technological advancements?

Many businesses are forgetting the bedrock of SEO: making sure their sites are indexable, crawlable, and authoritative. These aren’t glamorous tasks, but they’re essential. If search engines can’t access or understand your content, no amount of AI optimization will help. Additionally, creating content that genuinely addresses user needs—rather than just stuffing keywords—is often sidelined. These fundamentals are critical because they align with how search engines, even AI-enhanced ones, prioritize results. They reward sites that are technically sound and user-focused, no matter how the tech evolves.

You’ve highlighted shifts in search like understanding intent and removing friction. How has the focus on user intent evolved, and why is it more important now?

Understanding user intent has moved beyond just matching keywords to figuring out the ‘why’ behind a search. Years ago, it was enough to rank for a term; now, it’s about predicting what a user hopes to achieve—whether it’s finding a quick answer, a product, or inspiration. This matters more today because search engines, especially with AI integration, are better at interpreting nuanced queries. If your content doesn’t align with that deeper intent, you’re invisible, no matter how optimized your keywords are. It’s about delivering the right experience at the right moment.

What does removing friction mean in the context of search, and how do platforms reward this approach?

Removing friction is all about making the user’s journey as seamless as possible. Think of it as eliminating any barrier—be it slow load times, confusing navigation, or irrelevant content—that stops someone from getting what they need. Platforms like Google reward this by prioritizing sites that offer a smooth experience, often through higher rankings or featured snippets. For example, if your site answers a query directly and visually, like showcasing a recipe with clear images, users stay longer and engage more, signaling to the platform that your content is valuable.

How is monetization shaping search results, and what does this mean for businesses trying to improve their visibility?

Monetization is increasingly influencing how search results are structured. Platforms are prioritizing content or listings that drive revenue, whether through ads, sponsored results, or partnerships. For businesses, this means organic visibility often competes with paid placements, and you need a strategy that balances both. It’s not just about being helpful anymore; it’s about being strategic in how you position your content or products to align with these monetization trends. If you ignore this, you risk being pushed down the page by those who play the game.

Can you share an example from your experience where adapting to search changes led to significant results for a brand?

Absolutely. I once worked with a beverage brand where we noticed subtle shifts in how search results prioritized visual content for drink recipes. We analyzed what users were likely seeking—colorful cocktails or specific ingredients—and revamped the site to highlight those elements front and center. By focusing on vibrant imagery and easy-to-follow recipes, we aligned with the platform’s push for engaging, user-friendly experiences. The result was a massive spike in traffic, with millions of visits, because we adapted to what the search engine valued at that moment.

With AI tools often favoring consensus over originality, how can businesses with innovative ideas ensure they’re still discoverable?

AI systems tend to summarize widely accepted ideas, so if you’re introducing something groundbreaking, you can’t just rely on being different. You need to anchor your innovation to familiar concepts. For instance, if you’ve created a new tech tool, relate it to existing solutions by using terms users already know. Reflect their language and connect your fresh idea to legacy ideas. This bridging makes your content recognizable to AI systems, increasing the chances of showing up in results while still highlighting what makes you unique.

What advice do you have for our readers who are looking to refocus their SEO and marketing strategies in this AI-driven era?

My biggest piece of advice is to go back to the basics while embracing the new landscape. Start by ensuring your site is technically sound—crawlable, fast, and user-friendly. Then, dive deep into understanding your audience’s intent and problems through tools like AI search platforms or even simple query analysis. Ask yourself why your brand or product isn’t showing up for relevant searches and use those insights to close the gap. Finally, don’t get lost in AI hype—use it as a tool to enhance, not dictate, your strategy. Focus on delivering real value, and the visibility will follow.

Explore more

Hotels Must Rethink Recruitment to Attract Top Talent

With decades of experience guiding organizations through technological and cultural transformations, HRTech expert Ling-Yi Tsai has become a vital voice in the conversation around modern talent strategy. Specializing in the integration of analytics and technology across the entire employee lifecycle, she offers a sharp, data-driven perspective on why the hospitality industry’s traditional recruitment models are failing and what it takes

Trend Analysis: AI Disruption in Hiring

In a profound paradox of the modern era, the very artificial intelligence designed to connect and streamline our world is now systematically eroding the foundational trust of the hiring process. The advent of powerful generative AI has rendered traditional application materials, such as resumes and cover letters, into increasingly unreliable artifacts, compelling a fundamental and costly overhaul of recruitment methodologies.

Is AI Sparking a Hiring Race to the Bottom?

Submitting over 900 job applications only to face a wall of algorithmic silence has become an unsettlingly common narrative in the modern professional’s quest for employment. This staggering volume, once a sign of extreme dedication, now highlights a fundamental shift in the hiring landscape. The proliferation of Artificial Intelligence in recruitment, designed to streamline and simplify the process, has instead

Is Intel About to Reclaim the Laptop Crown?

A recently surfaced benchmark report has sent tremors through the tech industry, suggesting the long-established narrative of AMD’s mobile CPU dominance might be on the verge of a dramatic rewrite. For several product generations, the market has followed a predictable script: AMD’s Ryzen processors set the bar for performance and efficiency, while Intel worked diligently to close the gap. Now,

Trend Analysis: Hybrid Chiplet Processors

The long-reigning era of the monolithic chip, where a processor’s entire identity was etched into a single piece of silicon, is definitively drawing to a close, making way for a future built on modular, interconnected components. This fundamental shift toward hybrid chiplet technology represents more than just a new design philosophy; it is the industry’s strategic answer to the slowing