Redefining Success Metrics in Email Marketing: From Open Rates to Meaningful Engagement

The email channel remains a highly popular marketing medium among a wide range of customer demographics. However, recent changes in email measurability have raised concerns among marketers, potentially impacting how they interpret and leverage this channel in the future.

The Decreased Email Measurability

As we navigate through the dynamic marketing landscape, the measurability of email campaigns has been severely affected this year. These changes primarily stem from alterations in pixel fires, which are no longer generated if emails are delivered to spam or if devices are not connected to Wi-Fi or a power source. This loss of email measurability creates challenges for marketers in accurately gauging campaign performance.

The Inflation of Open Rates

One striking outcome of the changes in email measurability is the significant increase in email open rates. Year-on-year, open rates have nearly doubled, with a notable 13 percent jump, reaching a high of 31.8 percent. However, it is crucial to note that this inflation is driven by bot accounts taking advantage of a change in Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) policy. Consequently, questions have been raised regarding the accuracy of open rates as a true measurement of campaign effectiveness.

Stability of Click-Through Rates

While click-through rates have remained stable year-on-year, with a consistent 1.5% rate, they have declined compared to two years ago (at 2%). However, amidst the overall backdrop of performance marketing effectiveness, this performance is relatively strong. As consumer demand declines during the cost-of-living crisis, performance marketers are finding it increasingly challenging to generate the desired response.

Deliverability Rates: A Steady Starting Point

At the beginning of the email journey, deliverability rates have remained stable, reaching an impressive 97.9% in 2022. Despite the challenges in email measurability and engagement, this statistic highlights the initial success in reaching recipients’ inboxes.

The Limitations of Open Rates

With the introduction of Apple’s MPP, open rates can no longer provide a reliable measure of subscriber engagement. The inflation caused by bot accounts undermines the accuracy, making it imperative for marketers to reconsider their reliance on this metric as the sole measurement of success.

Developing Fresh Strategies for Meaningful Engagement

In light of the limitations of open rates, marketers must acknowledge the need to analyze a selected range of metrics that truly matter to drive meaningful engagement. It is no longer sufficient to rely solely on open rates and click-through rates. Marketers should explore alternative indicators such as conversion rates, customer lifetime value, and engagement duration to understand the true impact of their email campaigns.

The changes in email measurability, driven by factors like Apple’s MPP, have undoubtedly affected how marketers interpret the effectiveness of their email campaigns. With the inflation of open rates and the challenges faced in generating a response amidst declining consumer demand, it is imperative for marketers to embrace a fresh approach. Recognizing the limitations of open rates as a sole metric, a deeper analysis of meaningful engagement metrics is necessary to drive successful email marketing strategies and foster stronger connections with target audiences. By adapting and evolving in response to these changes, marketers can navigate the shifting landscape and continue to leverage the power of email marketing effectively.

Explore more

Why Do Talent Management Strategies Fail and How to Fix Them?

What happens when the systems meant to reward talent and dedication instead deepen unfairness in the workplace? Across industries, countless organizations invest heavily in talent management strategies, aiming to build a merit-based culture where the best rise to the top. Yet, far too often, these efforts falter, leaving employees disillusioned and companies grappling with inequity and inefficiency. This pervasive issue

Mastering Digital Marketing for NGOs in 2025: A Guide

In a world where over 5 billion people are online daily, NGOs face an unprecedented opportunity to amplify their missions through digital channels, yet the challenge of cutting through the noise has never been greater. Imagine an organization like Dianova International, working across 17 countries on critical issues like health, education, and gender equality, struggling to reach the right audience

How Can Leaders Prepare for the Cognitive Revolution?

Embracing the Intelligence Age: Why Leaders Must Act Now Imagine a world where machines not only perform tasks but also think, learn, and adapt alongside human workers, transforming every industry from manufacturing to healthcare in ways we are only beginning to comprehend. This is not a distant dream but the reality of the cognitive industrial revolution, often referred to as

Why Do Leaders Lack Empathy During Layoffs? New Survey Shows

Introduction In the current business landscape, layoffs have become a stark reality, cutting across industries from technology to retail, with countless employees facing the uncertainty of job loss. A staggering 53% of workers globally express fear of being laid off within the next year, reflecting a pervasive anxiety that shapes workplace dynamics and underscores a critical challenge for leaders. How

Employee Engagement Crisis: How to Restore Workplace Happiness

We’re thrilled to sit down with Ling-Yi Tsai, a renowned HRTech expert with decades of experience helping organizations navigate change through innovative technology. With a deep focus on HR analytics and the seamless integration of tech in recruitment, onboarding, and talent management, Ling-Yi offers invaluable insights into the pressing challenges of employee engagement and workplace well-being. In this conversation, we