Can Influencers Help Brands Rebuild Trust Among Distrusting Consumers?

Article Highlights
Off On

In today’s rapidly evolving digital landscape, maintaining trust is becoming increasingly critical for brands in their quest to build loyal consumer bases. Trust, which has always been the cornerstone of brand-consumer relationships, has seen a substantial decline, especially in the United States, where trust levels between consumers and companies are at their lowest since 2016. The primary drivers of this distrust include concerns over data privacy, security, and the ethical use of artificial intelligence (AI). As generative AI technologies become more prevalent, anxieties within the consumer market are only intensifying.

The Growing Mistrust Among Younger Consumers

Distrust in Digital Age

The issue of mistrust is most pronounced among younger consumers, who are generally more tech-savvy and aware of privacy issues than older generations. For instance, while trust ratings for consumers aged 65 and older stand at 57%, the figure drops sharply to just 28% among those aged 18 to 24. This disparity highlights a growing skepticism among the younger demographic, who are more discerning about how their data is used and more critical of brand transparency.

Despite their wariness, these younger consumers are far from disengaged. They actively seek high-quality products and services and are particular about the experiences they gain from them. To navigate their purchasing decisions, they increasingly rely on influencers—individuals they perceive as unbiased and trustworthy sources. Influencers, unlike traditional advertisements or push communications, offer genuine recommendations, making them valuable allies for brands aiming to build trust.

Impact of Influencers

Influencers have dramatically transformed how brands reach and engage with their audience. According to Adobe, about 37% of Gen Zers have made purchases based on influencers’ recommendations. Even more compelling is the statistic that influencers are converting shoppers at a rate ten times higher than conventional social media posts. This immense influence is further exemplified during significant shopping periods like Cyber Week, where affiliates and partners, including social media influencers, drove a 19% revenue share, with a remarkable 23.4% year-over-year growth. These figures underscore the expanding impact of influencers in shaping consumer behavior and rebuilding trust.

Leveraging Influencers for Authentic Connections

Building Genuine Experiences

Clare Lawson, CEO of Ogilvy One EMEA, emphasizes that consumers are increasingly fatigued by traditional advertising and push communications. In contrast, they favor influencers who can create genuine connections by sharing real experiences. This ability to foster authenticity is essential for crafting effective customer experiences (CX). Rather than merely driving sales, influencers are reshaping how brands understand and connect with their customers, thereby presenting a critical opportunity for brands to develop more genuine and impactful CX strategies.

This paradigm shift necessitates brands to adapt their strategies, ensuring they provide influencers with the creative freedom to craft content that resonates with their audience. Daphne Robertson, VP of Customer Experience and Operations at #paid, highlights the importance of trusting creators to produce authentic content. By allowing influencers this autonomy, brands can achieve more meaningful engagement with their audiences. Although this transition may pose challenges, especially for brands accustomed to strict content control, embracing influencer autonomy is indispensable for success in the current digital competition.

Strategic Implementation

Implementing an influencer-driven strategy requires a thoughtful approach. Brands must carefully select influencers whose values align with their own, ensuring that the partnership appears natural and credible to the audience. Furthermore, maintaining open communication with influencers can help brands understand consumer sentiments and feedback more accurately. This collaborative relationship can lead to the co-creation of content that not only promotes products but also educates and engages the audience, fostering a deeper sense of trust.

Moreover, brands should continually evaluate the impact of their influencer campaigns. This assessment includes analyzing metrics such as engagement rates, conversion rates, and overall sentiment. By doing so, brands can fine-tune their strategies, making necessary adjustments to enhance effectiveness and reinforce trust. The dynamic nature of digital markets means that strategies must be flexible and responsive to evolving consumer expectations and technological advancements.

Conclusion with Future Considerations

In today’s rapidly changing digital world, building and maintaining trust is critical for brands aiming to create loyal customer bases. Trust, always a key element in brand-consumer relationships, has been significantly eroded, particularly in the United States. Currently, trust levels between consumers and companies are at their lowest since 2016. This decline in trust is primarily driven by concerns over data privacy, security, and the ethical use of artificial intelligence (AI). As generative AI technologies become more widespread, consumer anxiety is growing. People worry about how their data is being used and whether companies are safeguarding their information, adding complexity to the trust landscape. Additionally, ethical considerations surrounding AI usage further fuel distrust, compelling brands to address these issues transparently. In a time where digital interactions are the norm, brands need to prioritize transparency and ethical practices to rebuild and sustain consumer trust in a technology-driven era.

Explore more

AI Dominated the Retail Customer Experience in 2025

A retrospective analysis of 2025 reveals a retail landscape that underwent a seismic shift, where the steady evolution of customer experience was abruptly overtaken by a technological revolution powered by artificial intelligence. This transformation was not confined to a single sector or channel; it was a comprehensive overhaul that redefined the very nature of the relationship between consumers and brands.

Consumers Now Value Fairness Over Brand Loyalty

Why a Fair Price Now Trumps a Familiar Name In an economic climate defined by persistent inflation and heightened consumer anxiety, the long-standing relationship between brands and their customers is being fundamentally rewritten. The traditional pillars of brand loyalty—heritage, marketing, and perceived quality—are buckling under the weight of financial pressure. A new, more discerning consumer has emerged, one who is

What Replaced ‘The Customer Is Always Right’?

Beneath the hum of fluorescent lights in contact centers and across the polished floors of retail establishments, a quiet but firm rebellion has been dismantling one of the most foundational maxims in business history. For over a century, the phrase “the customer is always right” served as a revolutionary North Star for service-oriented businesses. This once-powerful principle, however, has evolved

AI Elevates the Human Role in Customer Service

The long-promised fusion of artificial intelligence and customer service has moved from a theoretical future to a tangible, operational reality for businesses worldwide, with 2024 marking a definitive period of widespread technological adoption. As organizations navigate this new landscape, they face a central and defining challenge: how to strategically integrate the immense power of advanced technologies like AI while carefully

AI Coding Boom Burdens DevOps With Flawed Code

The Unseen Cost of Accelerated Development The rapid integration of artificial intelligence into software development, heralded as a revolutionary leap in productivity, is paradoxically creating a significant and growing strain on DevOps teams. A global survey by Sonar reveals a striking trend: while developers are embracing AI coding assistants at an unprecedented rate, this adoption is flooding CI/CD pipelines with