As the digital landscape continues to evolve, the relationship between Wi-Fi and private cellular networks is witnessing an ambitious transformation. This shift is driven by the increasing consumer demand for seamless connectivity that spans both indoor and outdoor environments. Pioneering industry groups like the Wireless Broadband Alliance (WBA) are championing greater interoperability between Wi-Fi and private cellular networks, which hold immense promise for enterprises and end-users alike.
Historically, the interaction between cellular and Wi-Fi networks has been marked by contention and competitiveness. Landmark incidents have highlighted this strained relationship, such as Verizon’s open criticism of Wi-Fi or AT&T’s network strain due to its early exclusivity on the iPhone, a situation salvaged only by leveraging Wi-Fi networks. These episodes underscore the ongoing debates over licensed (cellular) versus unlicensed (Wi-Fi) spectra, reflecting a continual tug-of-war between these networking domains.
The Shift Toward Collaboration
In recent years, a notable shift towards collaboration has emerged, particularly visible in private network deployments. Enterprises, many of which already rely heavily on Wi-Fi networks, are finding the integration of devices that can seamlessly leverage both Wi-Fi and private cellular technologies advantageous. This integration promises to enhance connectivity solutions across campuses and similar environments, potentially unlocking a range of synergistic capabilities.
However, the path to achieving this technological convergence is fraught with obstacles. Claus Hetting, CEO and chairman of Wi-Fi Now, remains skeptical about the feasibility of seamless handovers between private 5G and Wi-Fi in the near future. He attributes these challenges to the intrinsic complexity and the lack of substantial market incentives. Hetting points to the “whole 3GPP machinery” that governs cellular standards, contrasting it with the more nimble IEEE structure overseeing Wi-Fi specifications. Harmonizing these inherently different processes presents a formidable challenge, one that may not be easily overcome.
Additionally, the prevailing dominance of Wi-Fi within enterprises casts a shadow over the relatively limited adoption of private 5G networks. Hetting notes that even if convergence were to occur significantly, it would likely impact less than 5% of the enterprise Wi-Fi market at this stage. This disparity underscores the minimal current incentive to fully integrate these technologies despite their promising potential.
The Role of Industry Groups
In contrast to this cautious outlook, the WBA has identified ample incentive to advocate for this technological convergence. The WBA, which includes influential members such as AT&T, Boingo Wireless, Boldyn Network, BT Group, Cisco, Comcast, and Nokia, promotes an approach that leverages the strengths of both Wi-Fi and private cellular solutions. This advocacy for convergence and industry collaboration signals a positive trajectory toward unified networks, showcasing the concerted efforts to align these technologies.
Looking ahead, the WBA plans to initiate a new phase in 2025, focusing on the technical aspects of merging private 5G and Wi-Fi. This phase involves developing new industry standards for radio access technology (RAT) roaming, traffic steering, and quality of experience (QoE) metrics. The ultimate goal is for enterprises to benefit from the speed and reliability of 5G, alongside the extensive coverage and flexibility that Wi-Fi provides, creating a harmonious blend of these networking technologies.
A significant part of this alignment lies in the concept of “identity” within networks. OpenRoaming, a project led by the Wi-Fi industry, aims to make Wi-Fi roaming as seamless as cellular roaming, eliminating the need for cumbersome passwords when connecting to secure Wi-Fi networks. The WBA is collaborating closely with 3GPP to extend OpenRoaming to private cellular networks, thereby enhancing network flexibility and user experience for IT managers and end-users alike.
Market Demand and Device Integration
As industry groups like the WBA continue to advance these goals, an important question arises: Is there significant demand for greater convergence and the need to support handoffs between Wi-Fi and private 5G networks? Adlane Fellah, chief analyst at Maravedis, provides an affirmative response, citing the growing expectations of end-users for seamless connectivity transitions between indoor and outdoor environments. This rising demand underscores the importance of pursuing these technological integrations.
Fellah suggests various approaches to achieve this convergence. One method involves improved handoff management, as addressed in 3GPP Release 16. Another approach is dual connectivity, where 5G serves as a backbone for high-reliability scenarios while Wi-Fi provides cost-efficient localized coverage. This multi-faceted strategy necessitates that devices, particularly handsets, incorporate radios supporting both Wi-Fi and private or public 5G, along with optimized antennas to handle multiple bands without interference. Such integration would significantly enhance the user experience and operational efficiency of these devices.
An encouraging development in this context is the increasing interest in integrating cellular connectivity into ARM-powered laptops, which have traditionally been Wi-Fi-centric. This trend highlights the evolving landscape of device integration and showcases the potential for broader opportunities in the commercial sector. Protocols such as ultra-wideband (UWB) and Wi-Fi HaLow present substantial opportunities for IoT-associated use cases, further emphasizing the importance of convergence in advancing technological capabilities.
Industry Players and Innovations
Contrary to a cautious outlook, the WBA sees substantial incentives in advocating for technological convergence. The WBA comprises key players like AT&T, Boingo Wireless, Boldyn Network, BT Group, Cisco, Comcast, and Nokia. It supports an integrated approach harnessing both Wi-Fi and private cellular solutions. This advocacy indicates a promising direction toward unified networks, highlighting efforts to synchronize these technologies.
Looking forward, the WBA intends to launch a new phase in 2025, targeting the technical facets of merging private 5G and Wi-Fi. This phase will involve creating new industry standards for radio access technology (RAT) roaming, traffic steering, and quality of experience (QoE) metrics. The ultimate aim is for businesses to enjoy the speed and reliability of 5G, coupled with the extensive coverage and flexibility of Wi-Fi, resulting in a seamless combination of these networking technologies.
A key element of this alignment is the notion of “identity” within networks. The Wi-Fi industry’s OpenRoaming project aspires to make Wi-Fi roaming as effortless as cellular roaming, doing away with annoying passwords for secure Wi-Fi connections. The WBA is working closely with 3GPP to expand OpenRoaming to private cellular networks, thus boosting network flexibility and improving user experience for both IT managers and end-users.