Is 5G Too Advanced for Current Mobile Broadband Needs?

The march of technology is relentless, with each wave promising to be the one that revolutionizes our lives. At the epicenter of recent tech breakthroughs lies 5G, a leap forward in mobile broadband that is significantly more powerful than its predecessor. Boasting high-speed data transmission and the ability to handle a massive number of connected devices, this newest iteration of cellular technology has spurred excitement and anticipation across industries worldwide. But a point raised by Stefan Pongratz of the Dell’Oro Group challenges the current narrative: Could it be possible that 5G’s advanced capabilities are a tad too sophisticated for present-day needs, especially when evaluated against 4G+ applications powered by humans? This question isn’t posed lightly, considering the investments channeling into the Radio Access Network (RAN), which boasts a valuation edging between $35 to $40 billion.

Shifting Priorities in the RAN Market

Historically, the relationship between RAN revenue and Base Transceiver Station (BTS) shipments has closely followed network coverage phases. But the tides are changing—operators are now more focused on expanding network capacity in response to skyrocketing data traffic demands. This was particularly evident during the LTE era, which witnessed an explosive growth in data consumption, prompting network enhancements to keep up with capacity requirements. However, as 5G unfolds, the picture looks quite different. Pongratz observes that though 5G demonstrates steady data traffic growth at around 30%, anticipated to sustain a 25% compound annual growth rate over the next five years, its trajectory diverges from what was seen with 4G.

While it’s expected that 5G’s coverage phase will generate more revenue than that of 4G, owing to the necessity for new frequencies, the future patterns of capacity expansion are not so clearly etched. This creates a cloud of uncertainty for suppliers banking on a repeat of the LTE boom. When Chinese providers report only modest traffic growth, it sparks concerns of a disconnect between early expectations and actual demand. This disparity suggests that 5G, with all its advanced technical prowess, might find itself in a catch-22 situation; it needs significant data traffic growth to leverage its full potential, yet it’s unclear if and when this demand will materialize.

The Big Picture: Potential Vs. Reality

Currently, the tale of 5G is unfolding along two lines. There’s excitement over its prodigious ability to manage vast volumes of data and its economic benefits. Yet, there’s also the reality of unanticipated challenges in supply and demand. 5G is at a crossroads, equipped for a future that demands high bandwidth, but its immediate benefits are under scrutiny due to present-day data consumption patterns. This conflict underscores the pressing need for increased data traffic, which is crucial for 5G to live up to its anticipated advancements and steer the mobile technology landscape toward its plentiful potential.

The emergence of widely used mobile AR devices could be pivotal, possibly igniting a transformation in cellular AR traffic and renewing the RAN market. However, at this moment, the wireless industry needs to do more than create advanced technology; it must also spark the development of novel applications that spur a surge in data demand. According to Pongratz’s analysis, the real triumph of 5G may depend on the industry’s ability to inspire use cases that exploit the network’s vast potential. Without a significant uptick in data usage, the bright prospects of 5G may dim.

Explore more