Evaluating ChatGPT for Software Vulnerability Tasks: A Comparative Analysis

With its impressive 1.7 trillion parameters, ChatGPT has emerged as a powerful language model. However, its applicability to code-oriented tasks, such as software vulnerability analysis and repair, remains relatively unexplored. In this article, we delve into the evaluation of ChatGPT against code-specific models, specifically examining its performance on four vulnerability tasks using the Big-Vul and CVEFixes datasets. This comprehensive analysis sheds light on the potential limitations of using ChatGPT for software vulnerability tasks while emphasizing the need for domain-specific fine-tuning.

Evaluation of ChatGPT against code-specific models

To comprehensively evaluate ChatGPT’s performance, security analysts conducted experiments using the Big-Vul and CVEFixes datasets. These datasets provide a comprehensive set of vulnerability tasks, enabling a thorough comparison of ChatGPT against baseline methods. The evaluation focused on the F1-measure and top-10 accuracy metrics.

The results of the evaluation revealed that ChatGPT achieved an F1-measure of 10% and 29% on the Big-Vul and CVEFixes datasets, respectively. These scores were significantly lower compared to the other baseline methods. Similarly, the top-10 accuracy of ChatGPT was 25% and 65%, which again reflected the lowest performance among the examined models.

Analysis of Multiclass Accuracy

In addition to F1-measure and top-10 accuracy, multiclass accuracy was also considered as a crucial performance indicator. The analysis revealed that ChatGPT achieved the lowest multiclass accuracy of 13%, showcasing a striking 45%-52% difference from the best baseline model. These outcomes underscore the challenges faced by ChatGPT in accurately classifying vulnerability tasks across multiple classes.

Evaluation of Severity Estimation

Severity estimation holds paramount importance in vulnerability analysis to prioritize remediation efforts. However, ChatGPT’s performance in this regard proved to be unsatisfactory. The evaluation indicated that ChatGPT exhibited the highest mean squared error (MSE) of 5.4 and 5.85, implying its inaccurate severity estimation compared to the other baselines. This finding raises concerns about relying on ChatGPT for precise severity estimation in vulnerability assessment.

Assessment of Repair Patch Generation

One vital aspect of vulnerability repair is the generation of correct repair patches. Regrettably, ChatGPT failed to generate accurate repair patches in this evaluation. On the other hand, the baseline models demonstrated success in rectifying vulnerable functions, correctly repairing 7% to 30% of them. This stark contrast highlights the limitations of ChatGPT in generating effective repair solutions.

Limitations of fine-tuning

Fine-tuning is a commonly employed technique to optimize language models for specific tasks. However, in the case of ChatGPT, fine-tuning for vulnerability tasks is not viable due to proprietary parameters. This constraint further underlines the challenges in adapting ChatGPT directly for software vulnerability tasks.

The Importance of Domain-specific Fine-tuning

The analysis of ChatGPT’s performance in vulnerability tasks underscores the significance of domain-specific fine-tuning. The complexity and specificity of software vulnerability tasks necessitate the customization of language models like ChatGPT to better suit the requirements. This suggests the need for further research and work on fine-tuning or adapting ChatGPT specifically for software vulnerability tasks.

Comparison with previous studies

While previous studies have examined the effectiveness of large language models in automated program repair, they have not accounted for the latest versions of ChatGPT. This article bridges that gap by shedding light on the specific performance of ChatGPT in software vulnerability tasks. Additionally, the notable disparities in results indicate the necessity for dedicated exploration of ChatGPT’s potential in this domain.

In conclusion, the evaluation of ChatGPT for software vulnerability tasks reveals its limitations in comparison to code-specific models. The lower F1-measure, top-10 accuracy, multiclass accuracy, inaccurate severity estimation, and inability to generate correct repair patches highlight the challenges faced by ChatGPT in this context. The proprietary nature of its parameters further restricts fine-tuning for vulnerability tasks. As such, this study emphasizes the need for additional research and efforts to fine-tune or tailor ChatGPT specifically for software vulnerability analysis and repair. By addressing these challenges, ChatGPT could potentially be leveraged more effectively in securing software systems in the future.

Explore more

Creating Gen Z-Friendly Workplaces for Engagement and Retention

The modern workplace is evolving at an unprecedented pace, driven significantly by the aspirations and values of Generation Z. Born into a world rich with digital technology, these individuals have developed unique expectations for their professional environments, diverging significantly from those of previous generations. As this cohort continues to enter the workforce in increasing numbers, companies are faced with the

Unbossing: Navigating Risks of Flat Organizational Structures

The tech industry is abuzz with the trend of unbossing, where companies adopt flat organizational structures to boost innovation. This shift entails minimizing management layers to increase efficiency, a strategy pursued by major players like Meta, Salesforce, and Microsoft. While this methodology promises agility and empowerment, it also brings a significant risk: the potential disengagement of employees. Managerial engagement has

How Is AI Changing the Hiring Process?

As digital demand intensifies in today’s job market, countless candidates find themselves trapped in a cycle of applying to jobs without ever hearing back. This frustration often stems from AI-powered recruitment systems that automatically filter out résumés before they reach human recruiters. These automated processes, known as Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS), utilize keyword matching to determine candidate eligibility. However, this

Accor’s Digital Shift: AI-Driven Hospitality Innovation

In an era where technological integration is rapidly transforming industries, Accor has embarked on a significant digital transformation under the guidance of Alix Boulnois, the Chief Commercial, Digital, and Tech Officer. This transformation is not only redefining the hospitality landscape but also setting new benchmarks in how guest experiences, operational efficiencies, and loyalty frameworks are managed. Accor’s approach involves a

CAF Advances with SAP S/4HANA Cloud for Sustainable Growth

CAF, a leader in urban rail and bus systems, is undergoing a significant digital transformation by migrating to SAP S/4HANA Cloud Private Edition. This move marks a defining point for the company as it shifts from an on-premises customized environment to a standardized, cloud-based framework. Strategically positioned in Beasain, Spain, CAF has successfully woven SAP solutions into its core business