Coinbase Criticizes US Treasury’s Proposed Rulemaking on Cryptocurrency Mixing, Calling for a More Targeted Approach

Coinbase, one of the largest cryptocurrency exchanges in the United States, has voiced its criticism against the US Treasury’s proposed rulemaking on cryptocurrency mixing. In its official comment, Coinbase argued that the proposed rules fail to effectively address regulatory gaps while placing unnecessary burdens on crypto platforms. Let’s delve into Coinbase’s objections and proposed solutions in detail.

Inefficiency of reporting requirements

Coinbase expressed significant concerns regarding the proposed requirement for crypto platforms to report all cryptocurrency mixing activities, even those with legitimate purposes. The exchange deemed this approach inefficient and burdensome. According to Coinbase, such mandatory reporting would create an unnecessary data overload, making it difficult for authorities to discern suspicious transactions from ordinary cryptocurrency mixing.

Absence of monetary threshold for reporting

A crucial point raised by Coinbase is the lack of a monetary threshold for recordkeeping and reporting purposes. The exchange argued that without a threshold, the rulemaking would result in the bulk reporting of countless non-suspicious transactions, inundating regulators with unnecessary information. Coinbase emphasized that this would be a waste of time and resources for both the crypto platforms and the authorities.

There is a need for a targeted approach

Paul Grewal, the Chief Legal Officer of Coinbase, stressed the importance of a more targeted approach. Instead of mandatory bulk reporting, Coinbase proposed that specific guidance be provided, as has been done in other areas by the Treasury. Grewal highlighted that this approach would be more effective in achieving the desired goal of enhancing transparency surrounding crypto mixing activities.

Goal of enhancing transparency

The proposed rulemaking by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), a branch of the US Treasury, aims to enhance transparency in the realm of crypto mixing activities. However, Coinbase argued that the current approach does not effectively fulfill this objective and instead places excessive burdens on crypto platforms without sufficient justification.

Proposal for Threshold Implementation

To address the issues arising from bulk reporting, Coinbase has proposed that FinCEN introduce a threshold, whereby only transactions above a certain value would be subject to reporting. This threshold would help eliminate the reporting of numerous small and non-suspicious transactions, focusing the regulators’ attention on higher-value and potentially more suspicious activities.

Focus on recordkeeping

In its comment, Coinbase recommended shifting the focus from mandatory reporting to recordkeeping. By prioritizing recordkeeping instead, crypto platforms can mitigate privacy and security risks associated with mandatory reporting. This approach would strike a balance between regulatory requirements and protecting user privacy.

Impact of new rules

If FinCEN’s new rules are implemented, they would classify the mixing of convertible virtual currencies as a “primary money laundering concern.” This classification would affect not only dedicated tumblers like Tornado Cash, but also service providers utilizing basic privacy protocols. Coinbase drew attention to the significant implications this would have on various existing cryptocurrency services and their ability to operate.

Legal basis for rulemaking

FinCEN’s rulemaking is grounded in Section 311 of the USA Patriot Act, which grants the Treasury Secretary the authority to identify and take special measures against entities classified as “primary money laundering concerns.” While Coinbase acknowledges the need for regulatory oversight in the crypto industry, it asserts that the proposed rulemaking fails to strike the right balance between oversight and the industry’s ability to innovate and flourish.

Coinbase has raised valid concerns about the US Treasury’s proposed rulemaking on cryptocurrency mixing. The exchange believes that the current approach lacks specificity, places unnecessary burdens on crypto platforms, and fails to effectively address regulatory gaps. Coinbase strongly urges a more targeted approach, including the introduction of a monetary threshold and a focus on recordkeeping rather than mandatory reporting. It remains to be seen how the US Treasury will respond to these criticisms and whether any revisions to the rulemaking will be made.

Explore more

Unlock Success with the Right CRM Model for Your Business

In today’s fast-paced business landscape, maintaining a loyal customer base is more challenging than ever, with countless tools and platforms vying for attention behind the scenes in marketing, sales, and customer service. Delivering consistent, personalized care to every client can feel like an uphill battle when juggling multiple systems and data points. This is where customer relationship management (CRM) steps

7 Steps to Smarter Email Marketing and Tech Stack Success

In a digital landscape where billions of emails flood inboxes daily, standing out is no small feat, and despite the rise of social media and instant messaging, email remains a powerhouse, delivering an average ROI of $42 for every dollar spent, according to recent industry studies. Yet, countless brands struggle to capture attention, with open rates stagnating and conversions slipping.

Why Is Employee Retention Key to Boosting Productivity?

In today’s cutthroat business landscape, a staggering reality looms over companies across the United States: losing an employee costs far more than just a vacant desk, and with turnover rates draining resources and a tightening labor market showing no signs of relief, businesses are grappling with an unseen crisis that threatens their bottom line. The hidden cost of replacing talent—often

How to Hire Your First Employee for Business Growth

Hiring the first employee represents a monumental shift for any small business owner, marking a transition from solo operations to building a team. Picture a solopreneur juggling endless tasks—client calls, invoicing, marketing, and product delivery—all while watching opportunities slip through the cracks due to a sheer lack of time. This scenario is all too common, with many entrepreneurs stretching themselves

Is Corporate Espionage the New HR Tech Battleground?

What happens when the very tools designed to simplify work turn into battlegrounds for corporate betrayal? In a stunning clash between two HR tech powerhouses, Rippling and Deel, a lawsuit alleging corporate espionage has unveiled a shadowy side of the industry. With accusations of data theft and employee poaching flying, this conflict has gripped the tech world, raising questions about