Pro Line Sports, a British Columbia employer, is facing a wrongful dismissal lawsuit after terminating its employee, Dionne, for opening a package meant for one of the company’s owners. The incident took place when Dionne, who worked in sales support and customer service, accessed the package to obtain her wage statement, which was often delayed by the company. The Civil Resolution Tribunal (CRT) judged the dismissal unjust, awarding Dionne compensation.
Dionne was let go on October 17, providing her with two weeks’ pay in lieu of notice. Pro Line claimed her breach of trust justified immediate dismissal. However, the tribunal member Micah Carmody found the actions inappropriate but not severe enough to constitute grounds for termination without notice. Without exhibiting explicit remorse, Dionne was honest and did not have malicious intentions, which contributed to the CRT’s decision.
The tribunal pointed out that Pro Line failed to treat the incident as a significant privacy breach, did not update its policies, and did not consider lesser disciplinary measures. This undermined the company’s stance on the supposed severity of the issue. As a result, the tribunal awarded Dionne nine weeks’ pay, taking into account her employment duration, hourly wage, and job responsibilities.
Ultimately, Dionne received $5,518, including the small claims limit amount, interest, and tribunal fees. This case highlights the necessity for employers to handle privacy breaches with appropriate corrective measures and fair treatment of employees. It also serves as a reminder to consult human resources when handling disciplinary actions, emphasizing the importance of a fair notice period and proportional responses to misconduct.