EEOC Plans New Pay Data Collection Rule Amid Employer Concerns

The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is renewing its efforts to collect pay data from employers, marking a significant step in addressing wage disparities in workplaces across the country. This comes after a decade of alternating starts and stops regarding the collection of such data. Initially introduced during the Obama administration in 2017, the requirement for pay data collection faced a substantial setback under the Trump administration, which cited the Paperwork Reduction Act as a reason to halt the effort, arguing that it imposed an undue burden on employers. However, the EEOC received a brief reprieve when a 2019 court ruling reinstated the requirements. Nevertheless, the EEOC decided to abandon the endeavor after finding the process excessively burdensome. In spite of these setbacks, the commission is now poised to take another shot at refining this initiative.

Historical Challenges and Renewed Efforts

Despite encountering numerous obstacles, the EEOC has shown a sustained interest in the potential of pay data collection. The regulatory body’s persistence stems from the belief that, despite earlier drawbacks, a well-structured process could yield significant benefits. In 2022, a study conducted by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine (NASEM) assessed the initial data and found it lacking in several aspects. The researchers pointed out issues such as incomplete datasets and inconsistencies in job and worker categorization. Despite these flaws, NASEM recognized that the collected data possessed potential value, stressing that with proper adjustments and refinements, it could greatly aid in scrutinizing pay disparities and fostering pay equity.

The consensus among experts and policymakers is that while the first implementation had its flaws, tweaking the data collection process to address these issues could make it a powerful tool for combating wage inequality. With this realization, the EEOC has set its sights on proposing a new rule by January 2025. Central to this new approach is the intention to gather public input, aiming to structure a process that is comprehensive yet not overly taxing for employers. This strategy reflects a broader regulatory agenda that seeks to engage the public more robustly in rulemaking processes, thus ensuring regulations are not only responsive but also equitable and sustainable.

Public Input and Regulatory Agenda

Gathering public input is not merely a formality for the EEOC; it is a cornerstone of its new approach. The commission acknowledges that insights from those most affected by the regulations can significantly improve the quality and durability of the resulting rules. This is epitomized in the 2024 Spring Regulatory Agenda, which emphasizes the administration’s commitment to involving stakeholders in policymaking. Sam Berger of the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs has highlighted the importance of feedback from the public. According to Berger, such input can facilitate the creation of rules that are more effective and long-lasting by incorporating diverse perspectives and addressing potential issues proactively.

The EEOC’s renewed push for pay data collection also underscores its commitment to transparency and accountability. The agency aims to demonstrate that involving stakeholders in the regulatory process can lead to more balanced and effective outcomes. By focusing on the quality and reliability of the data collected, the EEOC plans to use these insights to craft rules that strike a balance between the need for detailed, actionable data and the practical challenges employers face in providing this information. This nuanced approach is informed by past setbacks as well as recent studies, emphasizing the importance of refining the data collection process to yield meaningful insights without imposing excessive burdens.

Future Prospects and Industry Reactions

Gathering public input is more than a mere formality for the EEOC; it is foundational to its new strategy. The commission understands that insights from those directly impacted by regulations can significantly enhance the quality and longevity of the rules. This is clearly reflected in the 2024 Spring Regulatory Agenda, showcasing the administration’s dedication to engaging stakeholders in the policymaking process. Sam Berger from the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs has emphasized the critical role of public feedback. Berger asserts that such input can help develop rules that are both more effective and durable by incorporating a range of perspectives and addressing potential challenges proactively.

The EEOC’s renewed initiative to collect pay data emphasizes its commitment to transparency and accountability. By involving stakeholders, the agency aims to produce more balanced and effective regulations. The focus is on the quality and reliability of the collected data, using these insights to create rules that balance the need for detailed, actionable data with the practical challenges employers face in providing it. This informed approach, shaped by past setbacks and recent studies, aims to refine the data collection process to provide meaningful insights without imposing undue burdens on employers.

Explore more