In an unexpected revelation, the Insurity 2025 AI in Insurance Report uncovered a significant downturn in consumer confidence regarding the use of artificial intelligence (AI) within the property and casualty (P&C) insurance sector, far surpassing previous shifts seen in earlier years. Once heralded as a breakthrough technology capable of revolutionizing insurance processes, AI now faces increasing skepticism and wariness from consumers who question its transparency, reliability, and overall value proposition.
Decline in Consumer Confidence
Survey Findings and Impact
The survey, which involved over 1,000 randomly selected adults across the U.S., revealed that a mere 20% of Americans now view the use of AI in P&C insurance positively. This marks a troubling decline from the 29% noted in 2024. Additionally, it found that 44% of consumers are less inclined to purchase a policy from an insurer utilizing AI, a slight increase from 42% the previous year. These statistics underscore a growing distrust and concern over the practical application of AI in decision-making processes that directly impact consumers’ financial and personal well-being.
Moreover, the survey highlighted a worrying trend regarding interactions with AI. Positive interactions plunged dramatically, from 63% in 2024 to 47% in 2025. This drastic reduction suggests that consumers are encountering AI systems that fail to meet expectations, perhaps due to inaccuracies, lack of user-friendliness, or perceived biases in how decisions are rendered. While these figures paint a grim picture, they are also indicative of the urgent need for insurers to reassess and realign their AI strategies to better cater to consumer expectations and concerns.
Generational Differences
A more detailed examination of the survey data shows that generational differences play a pivotal role in shaping attitudes toward AI. All age groups, except Gen Z, exhibited a noticeable decline in positive sentiment toward AI between 2024 and 2025. Millennials saw the most significant drop, with only 26% maintaining a favorable view compared to 41% in 2024. Gen X and Baby Boomers also reported decreased approval, with sentiments declining from 34% to 20% and 13% to 10%, respectively.
Interestingly, Gen Z remained steady in their perception of AI, with 25% viewing it positively, unchanged from the previous year. This peculiar steadiness among the youngest demographic warrants further investigation, as it may point to differing expectations or experiences that buffer them against the prevailing skepticism. Understanding the unique factors influencing each generation’s perspective on AI can provide insurers with the nuanced insights needed to address specific concerns effectively.
Addressing Skepticism
Transparency and Communication
Leading voices in the industry, such as Sylvester Mathis, Chief Revenue and Chief Insurance Officer at Insurity, emphasize the critical need for transparency in AI’s use. Mathis stresses that clear communication about AI’s benefits and responsible usage is essential if insurers are to transform consumer skepticism into confidence. The challenge lies in presenting AI not as a black box but as a transparent, understandable, and reliable tool that augments rather than replaces human expertise.
Insurers should prioritize educating their customers about AI-driven processes, ensuring that policyholders understand how AI supports faster claims processing, real-time alerts, and more accurate risk assessments. By demystifying AI and providing clear, data-driven success stories, insurers can build a strong narrative around the tangible benefits that AI can offer, ultimately fostering greater acceptance and trust.
Opportunity for Education and Demonstration
Despite the negative trends highlighted by the report, there remain actionable opportunities for insurers to regain and even bolster consumer trust in AI. Educating consumers about the capabilities and limitations of AI is crucial. This educational effort should not only focus on explaining AI’s functionalities but also showcase real-world examples where AI has positively impacted the claims process or enhanced overall customer experience.
Demonstrable benefits through data-driven results can be a game-changer in rebuilding confidence. By being proactive in sharing success stories and quantifiable outcomes, insurers can illustrate the value that AI brings to their services. Moreover, fostering a dialogue with consumers, where feedback is actively sought and addressed, can turn skepticism into constructive engagement. Understanding consumer concerns and adapting AI applications to address those issues directly can transform the AI narrative within the P&C insurance sector.
Future Considerations
Technological Improvements and Consumer Trust
The findings from the Insurity 2025 AI in Insurance Report underscore an urgent need for greater transparency, improved consumer education, and tangible demonstrations of AI’s benefits. The challenge for insurers lies in presenting AI in a way that builds trust, explaining its role not as an opaque system of algorithms but as a reliable and accountable aid to human decision-makers. By focusing on the transparency of AI’s purpose, such as real-time severe weather monitoring and alert systems, insurers can improve consumer trust and demonstrate the true value AI brings to policyholders.
Strategic Adaptation
The drop in trust is considerably more significant than the changes recorded in previous years. AI, once celebrated as a groundbreaking technology with the potential to revolutionize insurance processes, is now increasingly met with skepticism and doubt by consumers. Key concerns center around the transparency, reliability, and overall value of AI in handling insurance matters. These apprehensions indicate a shift in consumer perception, posing challenges for the industry’s future adoption of AI technologies. Despite its initial promise of efficiency and innovation, AI must now address these growing doubts to regain consumer trust and demonstrate its true benefits in the P&C insurance realm.